Lake Erie's Middle Island
Courtesy of Wikimedia
Lake Erie’s Middle Island is Canada’s southernmost possession, lying just south of Pelee Island. Over seen by Parks Canada, the 45-acre island is home to hundreds of heron gulls, thousands of cormorants, even pelicans, and warblers during spring migration.
During Prohibition, Middle Island served as an important way station and haven for rumrunners, smuggling whiskey and premium beers across the lake from Canada to the U. S. mainland.
Toledo underworld figure Joe Roscoe, who had ties to the Purple Gang in Detroit,
owned a large portion of the island. He built an air strip and a plush hotel
that he called “The Lake Erie Fishing Club” although there was little fishing
going on. It featured 7 bedrooms, fireplaces, electricity, large,
beautifully-situated verandahs. The basement, carved deep into the bedrock,
sported a casino.
Roscoe hired his buddies,
former convicted liquor smugglers Ted and Bert Angus, to manage the “club
house” on a percentage basis from 1928 to 1932.
Along with other gangsters, Al Capone is rumored to have stayed at
Roscoe’s establishment.
Thomas H. Langlois Collection
Thomas H. Langlois Collection
When Prohibition ended and there was no longer money to be made in smuggling liquor, Roscoe continued his business as a hotel and restaurant, hosting vacationers, fishing charters, and local sailors. As many as 200 boaters a day were treated to sumptuous pheasant dinners.
Roscoe also owned one of
the fastest boats on Lake Erie. His “Rainbow” was a 32-foot custom built craft
that featured a 500 horsepower, 12-cylinder V-type Liberty motor. After
Prohibition, Roscoe used it to commute from the island to Toledo where his wife
Ganey and her father, Jack Broadway, managed his 42nd Street Café on
Broadway and the Jovial Club on St. Clair.
Some of his gangster
friends like Alvin “Creepy” Karpis and Hugh Campbell were not as lucky as Joe.
They turned to kidnapping and robbery to make a living. After the kidnapping of
Edward Bremer in 1934, Karpis hid out in Toledo for a time. It was Joe who found
Karpis and his pal Campbell a place to lay low with his friend Edith Barry, who
ran a brothel on Southard Avenue.
Karpis again turned to Joe Roscoe after his gang’s daring mail train robbery at Garrettsville, Ohio in November of 1935. Joe arranged Karpis’ escape via a flight from Port Clinton to Hot Springs, Arkansas.
But Hoover and his G-men caught
up to Karpis. He was sentenced to life in prison on Alcatraz, the last of the Depression-era
gangsters. It wasn’t until January 1937
that the FBI arrested Joe in Miami. Later that year, he was sentenced to 7 ½
years in Leavenworth for his part in assisting Karpis. Having served his time, Joe
returned to Toledo, where he died in 1965. According to his obituary, he sold
Middle Island shortly before his death.
Today, swallows are the
lone guests at Roscoe’s hotel, now nothing but a mere shell. Only the stone foundation
of the burned out lighthouse and the overgrown air strip remain as evidence of
those heady days on Middle Island.
To see some fine photographs of Roscoe's abandoned hotel, please go to flickr to view images taken by Ken Bell in 2007.
Interesting dialogue of things on Lake Erie that happened many years ago.
ReplyDeleteIn 1968 my husband was the caretaker of the Island for a group of 4 Ohio men. They used the island to fish and vacation. My husband was their fishing guide and upkeep manager. In August of that year my husband was walking with an uncapped gas can on his way to burn a pile of brush. The fumes from the can wafted back to a pile already burning and it exploded and he was burnt everywhere but where his sunglasses and bathing trunks covered. He was near the lakeside so jumped in to extinguish the flames. He hailed a passing boat that took him to Pelee Island where a pilot flew him to Leamington, Ontario where he spent the next month in hospital. bjmartin
ReplyDeleteI am sorry to learn of this horrifying incident experienced by your husband. Thankfully, he recovered. I did not follow the sale of the island other than to learn that Mr. Roscoe sold it shortly before his death in 1965. As I mentioned in the article, this statement came from his obituary. Thank you for writing. Nan
ReplyDeleteHello,
ReplyDeleteI am an editor at a magazine in Canada and am looking to speak to anyone with firsthand knowledge or experience and/or photos of the Middle Island Fishing Club. Would the blog owner or any of the commenters be able to point me in the right direction? Please email me at sexton@outdoorcanada.ca if you have any sources or photos that we could use. Thanks for your time.
Hi bjmartin - my dad was one of the businessmen who owned the island in mid 1960s to mid 1970s. He remembers your husband’s accident vividly, and says he travelled to Leamington to visit Donnie in the hospital. He has great memories of spending time with him on the island.
ReplyDelete